Updated: Dating Kryptonite

Update: So after my Judaism class today, this kid says to me: "Nalton?" I turn and this kid looks familiar to me. I'm racking my brain trying to place him in one of my classes that I've TAed, but I can't come up with anything. Then it hits me: Undergrad1. He's in my Judaism class. And! Undergrad2 is also in the class, just in a different section. I never thought I would see these two boys again, and there one of them was, in my Judaism class...